Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Goodnight Moon and the Smoker's Dilemma

I chose the last picture of Goodnight Moon illustrator Clement Hurd. The picture is on the dust jacket of the book where the illustrator's biography is located. However unlike the original version where Hurd is holding a cigarette, he instead has his hand open as if "trying to get someone to repay him 2o bucks." The picture was most likely manipulated so that his smoking habits would not influence the children who read his books. Worried parents were probably the promoters of the change and the printing company did not wish bad publicity or plunging sales. Obviously the picture does not reveal itself in its truest form, but I don't believe this particular case is harmful. The cigarette could be taken or left and would not make a difference to the purpose of the work, the children's story. I believe that perhaps the company made the right decision to alter the photo in order to save children's opinions of smoking.

6 comments:

  1. The picture does look a little odd without something in his hand. But I can definitely understand and agree with you in that the company made the right choice to keep the image of smoking away from children.

    ReplyDelete
  2. yea I agree the picture is a bit odd but i like how they tried to omit the cigarettes

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting...I think for the most part I agree that this editing wasn't too harmful if it was for the greater good of being a positive role model for children.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like your different approach about the editing of a picture not being harmful. And agree, it probably was a good choice to no publish a picture of an author of a children's book smoking a cigarette.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a very interesting entry. It was something different than what other people did. Why would they put a man holding a cigarette on the cover of a children's book? I definitely agree with the decision to alter it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good choice of picture. I'm sure that you're correct about why the cigarette was edited out of his hand.

    ReplyDelete